Rank: ? (4278)
Member #: 5260

Muslims would always put Muhammad ahead of other prophets, but that I supposed is natural, even understandable, I supposed. I don't think they tired of listing his deeds, his victories in battles.

But you have to wonder if all of these are true or not. And wonder if some of it were made up by his followers to elevate him higher than he really is.

Moses was a lawgiver, so Muhammad had to be one.

Abraham, Moses, Joshua and David were great leaders in peace and victorious in war, so Muhammad had to be one also.

Jesus offered salvation through him, Muhammad had to offer the same.

Paul was visited by Jesus in a vision, on his road to Damascus, and lay the foundation of Christianity as we know it, through his writings. Muhammad was visited by the archangel Gabriel, and accepted revelation, even though Muhammad didn't or couldn't write a thing.

To me, it looked like Muslims are trying to amalgamate all the past prominent prophets and their qualities into one super-prophet. It sounds childish as it sound.

I don't know if anyone here have read The Iliad and The Odyssey, but it is the oldest and finest classic of its time. Past authors tried to match or achieve greater classics than Homer's 2 epics with their own epics, but in reality, they are trying to copy Homer's.

Virgil's Aeneid, the story of Aeneas and the Trojans living in Italy, near Rome, was like copying both the Odyssey in the 1st half of his epic, and the Iliad in the 2nd part of his epic. Virgil tried to make Aeneas like the hero Odysseus and Achilles, all roll into one.

Apollonius of Rhodes wrote about the Jason and Argonauts (Argonautica), but some of their adventures seemed like the Odyssey too. Though Apollonius' Jason seemed less heroic than Homer's Odysseus.

This is what Muhammad looked like to me, a copycat, to make him look like a superhero. It just make me wondered if all this just glamor or propaganda of Islam.

Rank: ? (4540)
Member #: 51

Have you read The Odyssey: A Modern Sequel by Nikos Kazantzakis? Although I like this author I find epic poems hard to read.

Rank: ? (4278)
Member #: 5260

No, I haven't read any Kanantzakis.

And epic poems are hard to read, and in the case of ancient epics, they are even harder to read. There are fit bit that I can't comprehend, due to me not living at that time, so languages are different, and don't easily translate into English very well, and sometimes they just don't make sense, due to author's talking gibberish.

Some people translate Homer's epics better than other. Homer was also very inventive in his style, and the translations I preferred on his epics are from Robert Fagles.

I found it difficult to read the Babylonian epic of Gilgamesh, and that of Old English epic of Beowulf.